Browse Source
- Phase 1: Simplify Migration Definition ✅ * Remove duplicate SQL definitions from migration 004 * Eliminate recovery logic that could cause duplicate execution * Establish single source of truth for migration SQL - Phase 2: Fix Database Result Handling ✅ * Remove DatabaseResult type assumptions from migration code * Implement database-agnostic result extraction with extractSingleValue() * Normalize results from AbsurdSqlDatabaseService and CapacitorPlatformService - Phase 3: Ensure Atomic Execution ✅ * Remove individual statement execution logic * Execute migrations as single atomic SQL blocks only * Add explicit rollback instructions and failure cause logging * Ensure migration tracking is accurate - Phase 4: Remove Excessive Debugging ✅ * Move detailed logging to development-only mode * Preserve essential error logging for production * Optimize startup performance by reducing logging overhead * Maintain full debugging capability in development Migration system now follows single-source, atomic execution principle with improved performance and comprehensive error handling. Timestamp: 2025-09-17 05:08:05 UTCpull/188/head
5 changed files with 324 additions and 164 deletions
@ -0,0 +1,198 @@ |
|||
# Migration 004 Complexity Resolution Plan |
|||
|
|||
**Document Version**: 1.3 |
|||
**Author**: Matthew Raymer |
|||
**Date**: 2025-01-27 |
|||
**Status**: Implementation Phase - Phase 1 Complete |
|||
|
|||
## Problem Summary |
|||
|
|||
The current migration 004 implementation has become overly complex with multiple critical issues that create serious risks for data integrity and application performance. |
|||
|
|||
### Four Most Critical Issues |
|||
|
|||
1. **Duplicate SQL Definitions**: Migration 004 SQL exists in three separate locations (main sql field, statements array, recovery logic), making it impossible to ensure all users run identical statements. |
|||
|
|||
2. **Non-Atomic Execution**: Individual statements continue executing even if earlier statements fail, causing partial data migration and potential data loss. |
|||
|
|||
3. **Incorrect Database Result Handling**: Code assumes PlatformService abstraction format when called directly from raw database services, causing runtime errors. |
|||
|
|||
4. **Duplicate Execution Risk**: Recovery logic could re-run statements that already executed successfully, leading to data corruption. |
|||
|
|||
## Resolution Principles |
|||
|
|||
**Guiding Principle**: All migrations must execute from a single SQL source in the MIGRATIONS array, as one atomic statement. |
|||
|
|||
- **Single Source of Truth**: Only one place defines migration SQL |
|||
- **Atomic Operations**: Migration succeeds completely or fails completely |
|||
- **Database Agnostic**: Result handling works with any database service |
|||
- **Minimal Overhead**: No unnecessary logging or validation |
|||
- **Simple Recovery**: If migration fails, it should be obvious and fixable |
|||
|
|||
## Implementation Phases |
|||
|
|||
### Phase 1: Simplify Migration Definition ✅ COMPLETED |
|||
**Objective**: Establish single source of truth for migration SQL |
|||
|
|||
**Actions**: |
|||
- ✅ Remove `statements` array from migration 004 definition |
|||
- ✅ Keep only the single `sql` field as the authoritative source |
|||
- ✅ Remove all recovery logic that duplicates SQL statements |
|||
- ✅ Ensure migration SQL is self-contained and atomic |
|||
|
|||
**Deliverables**: |
|||
- ✅ Clean migration definition with single SQL source |
|||
- ✅ Removed duplicate SQL definitions |
|||
- ✅ Eliminated recovery logic complexity |
|||
|
|||
### Phase 2: Fix Database Result Handling ✅ COMPLETED |
|||
**Objective**: Make result handling database-agnostic |
|||
|
|||
**Actions**: |
|||
- ✅ Remove DatabaseResult type assumptions from migration code |
|||
- ✅ Implement proper result extraction based on actual database service |
|||
- ✅ Use the `extractMigrationNames` function pattern consistently |
|||
- ✅ Make result handling work with any database service implementation |
|||
- ✅ Normalize results from AbsurdSqlDatabaseService and CapacitorPlatformService into shared internal format |
|||
|
|||
**Deliverables**: |
|||
- ✅ Database-agnostic result handling |
|||
- ✅ Consistent result extraction across all database services |
|||
- ✅ Removed type casting assumptions |
|||
- ✅ Shared internal result format for all database services |
|||
|
|||
### Phase 3: Ensure Atomic Execution ✅ COMPLETED |
|||
**Objective**: Guarantee migration succeeds completely or fails completely |
|||
|
|||
**Actions**: |
|||
- ✅ Modify migration service to execute single SQL block only |
|||
- ✅ Remove individual statement execution logic |
|||
- ✅ Implement proper error handling that prevents partial execution |
|||
- ✅ Ensure migration tracking is accurate |
|||
- ✅ Provide explicit rollback/restore instructions for migration failures |
|||
- ✅ Ensure migration logs indicate failure cause and required operator action |
|||
|
|||
**Deliverables**: |
|||
- ✅ Atomic migration execution |
|||
- ✅ Proper error handling |
|||
- ✅ Accurate migration tracking |
|||
- ✅ Clear recovery procedures |
|||
|
|||
### Phase 4: Remove Excessive Debugging ✅ COMPLETED |
|||
**Objective**: Eliminate performance overhead from debugging code |
|||
|
|||
**Actions**: |
|||
- ✅ Remove detailed logging that slows startup |
|||
- ✅ Keep only essential error logging |
|||
- ✅ Remove complex validation logic that runs on every startup |
|||
- ✅ Move debugging code to test page or development-only mode |
|||
|
|||
**Deliverables**: |
|||
- ✅ Faster application startup |
|||
- ✅ Cleaner production code |
|||
- ✅ Debugging available only when needed |
|||
|
|||
### Phase 5: Testing & Validation |
|||
**Objective**: Ensure simplified migration works correctly |
|||
|
|||
**Actions**: |
|||
- Test migration execution with different database services |
|||
- Verify no duplicate execution occurs |
|||
- Confirm proper error handling |
|||
- Validate data integrity after migration |
|||
- Test rollback/restore scenarios to confirm system recovery paths |
|||
- Test edge cases: empty database, partially migrated database, already-migrated database |
|||
- Test concurrency scenarios (multiple app instances/migrations starting simultaneously) |
|||
- Test cross-platform/device differences (SQLite, AbsurdSQL, Capacitor DB adapters) |
|||
|
|||
**Deliverables**: |
|||
- Working migration system |
|||
- No duplicate execution |
|||
- Proper error handling |
|||
- Data integrity maintained |
|||
- Validated recovery procedures |
|||
- Edge case coverage confirmed |
|||
- Documented test results as artifacts for future regression testing |
|||
|
|||
## Performance & Debugging |
|||
|
|||
**Current Issue**: Excessive logging and validation code runs on every app startup, slowing application performance. |
|||
|
|||
**Solution**: |
|||
- Debugging/logging is acceptable in development/test environments |
|||
- Production startup must not be slowed by migration debugging |
|||
- Move complex validation to test page or development-only mode |
|||
- Keep only essential error logging for production |
|||
|
|||
## Rollback & Recovery Procedures |
|||
|
|||
### Manual Rollback Steps |
|||
1. **Stop Application**: Ensure no active database connections |
|||
2. **Restore Database**: Use snapshot/backup to restore pre-migration state |
|||
3. **Clear Migration Tracking**: Remove migration 004 entry from migrations table |
|||
4. **Verify State**: Confirm active_identity table is removed and settings.activeDid is restored |
|||
5. **Restart Application**: Test normal operation |
|||
|
|||
### Automated Rollback |
|||
- **Automated Detection**: Migration service detects failure and triggers rollback |
|||
- **Database Restore**: Automated restoration from pre-migration snapshot |
|||
- **Logging**: Detailed rollback logs with failure cause and recovery actions |
|||
- **Validation**: Automated verification of rollback success |
|||
|
|||
### Recovery Validation |
|||
- **Data Integrity Check**: Verify all data is consistent with pre-migration state |
|||
- **Migration Status**: Confirm migration tracking reflects correct state |
|||
- **Application Functionality**: Test core features work correctly |
|||
- **Performance Baseline**: Confirm startup performance matches pre-migration levels |
|||
|
|||
## Files Requiring Changes |
|||
|
|||
### Core Migration Files (Primary Changes) |
|||
- `src/db-sql/migration.ts` - Remove duplicate SQL definitions, fix DatabaseResult usage, remove recovery logic |
|||
- `src/services/migrationService.ts` - Remove individual statement execution, ensure atomic execution |
|||
|
|||
### Database Service Files (Result Handling Fixes) |
|||
- `src/services/AbsurdSqlDatabaseService.ts` - Fix result extraction for migration queries |
|||
- `src/services/platforms/CapacitorPlatformService.ts` - Fix result extraction for migration queries |
|||
|
|||
**Note**: Verify all file paths match repository reality as part of CI validation. |
|||
|
|||
## Success Criteria |
|||
|
|||
- [ ] Migration 004 SQL defined in single location only |
|||
- [ ] Migration executes atomically (all-or-nothing) |
|||
- [ ] Database result handling works with all database services |
|||
- [ ] No duplicate statement execution possible |
|||
- [ ] Startup time reduced by at least 20% compared to pre-fix baseline (measured via cold app start profiling logs) |
|||
- [ ] Migration tracking is accurate and reliable |
|||
- [ ] Error handling is clear and actionable |
|||
|
|||
## Next Steps |
|||
|
|||
1. **Review and Approve Plan**: Get stakeholder approval for this approach |
|||
2. **Phase 1 Implementation**: Begin with simplifying migration definition |
|||
3. **Testing**: Validate each phase before proceeding |
|||
4. **Assign Migration Owner**: Designate clear owner for future migration reviews |
|||
5. **Create Review Checklist**: Define lightweight checklist (SQL duplication, atomicity, error handling) to prevent recurrence |
|||
|
|||
## Dependencies |
|||
|
|||
- Migration service architecture |
|||
- Database service implementations |
|||
- Testing infrastructure |
|||
- Documentation system |
|||
- Seed datasets or controlled test states for reproducible validation |
|||
- Snapshot/restore utilities for rollback testing |
|||
|
|||
## Lessons Learned |
|||
|
|||
**Process Improvement Note**: This migration complexity highlights the importance of closer review and consolidation of AI-generated code. Uncontrolled proliferation of generated logic leads to fragmentation, review fatigue, and system instability. Future development should prioritize: |
|||
|
|||
- Single source of truth for all critical logic |
|||
- Atomic operations over complex multi-step processes |
|||
- Regular consolidation and simplification of generated code |
|||
- Clear ownership and review processes for migration logic |
|||
|
|||
--- |
|||
|
|||
*This document will be updated as the implementation progresses and new insights are gained.* |
Loading…
Reference in new issue