docs: Add comprehensive callback and dual scheduling analysis

- Create detailed analysis of callback system requirements - Document dual scheduling method architecture (content fetch vs user notification) - Include implementation approach with realistic time estimates - Add complexity assessment and risk analysis - Provide technical considerations and security guidelines - Include testing strategy and performance impact analysis - Document design patterns and platform-specific resources Resolves: User feedback on callback system and dual scheduling needs
2025-08-26 11:22:17 +00:00
parent 361166da02
commit 05cebb09b5
1 changed files with 321 additions and 0 deletions
--- a/docs/CALLBACK_ANALYSIS.md
+++ b/docs/CALLBACK_ANALYSIS.md
@@ -0,0 +1,321 @@
 # Callback & Dual Scheduling Analysis
 **Document Created**: 2025-08-26 11:17:26 UTC  
 **Author**: Matthew Raymer  
 **Status**: 🔄 **RESEARCH & ANALYSIS**  
 **Priority**: 🔴 **HIGH** - Core functionality enhancement required
 ## 🎯 **REQUIREMENTS ANALYSIS**
 ### **User Feedback Summary**
 > "BTW, I still think it's worth starting a branch where we use the notification plugin, but a note on the plugin itself: seems like it'll need a couple things. One is to accept some callbacks (eg. for API calls out to a reporting service and then saving in the DB). The other is that I believe we need two 'schedule' methods, one that does the call-API-store-in-DB function and the other that does the retrieve-from-DB-and-notify-user function."
 ### **Core Requirements Identified**
 1. **Callback System**: Accept callbacks for external service integration
 2. **Dual Scheduling**: Separate content fetch from user notification
 3. **API Integration**: Support for external reporting services
 4. **Database Operations**: Callback-based storage and retrieval
 ---
 ## 🔍 **CURRENT IMPLEMENTATION ANALYSIS**
 ### **Existing Scheduling Method**
 ```typescript
 // Current single method approach
 async scheduleDailyNotification(options: NotificationOptions): Promise<void>
 ```
 **Current Behavior**:
 - Single method handles both content fetching and notification scheduling
 - Limited to basic URL fetching without callback support
 - No separation of concerns between data operations and user notification
 - Basic error handling without external service integration
 ### **Current API Call Handling**
 ```typescript
 // Basic URL fetching in Android implementation
 String url = call.getString("url", "");
 // No callback support for API responses
 // No database storage integration
 // No external service reporting
 ```
 ### **Gap Analysis**
 - ❌ **No callback mechanism** for external service integration
 - ❌ **No dual scheduling** - single method handles everything
 - ❌ **Limited API integration** - basic HTTP requests only
 - ❌ **No database callback support** for storage operations
 - ❌ **No reporting service integration** for analytics
 ---
 ## 🏗️ **PROPOSED ARCHITECTURE**
 ### **Dual Scheduling Methods**
 #### **Method 1: Content Fetch & Storage**
 ```typescript
 async scheduleContentFetch(options: ContentFetchOptions): Promise<void>
 ```
 **Purpose**: Handle API calls and database storage
 **Responsibilities**:
 - Make API calls to external services
 - Execute database storage callbacks
 - Handle retry logic and fallbacks
 - Report to analytics/reporting services
 - Cache content for later use
 #### **Method 2: User Notification**
 ```typescript
 async scheduleUserNotification(options: UserNotificationOptions): Promise<void>
 ```
 **Purpose**: Retrieve stored content and notify users
 **Responsibilities**:
 - Retrieve content from database/cache
 - Execute user notification callbacks
 - Handle notification display logic
 - Manage user interaction callbacks
 - Track notification engagement
 ### **Callback System Architecture**
 #### **Callback Types**
 ```typescript
 interface CallbackSystem {
  // API callbacks
  apiCallbacks: {
    onSuccess: (response: any) => Promise<void>;
    onError: (error: Error) => Promise<void>;
    onRetry: (attempt: number) => Promise<boolean>;
  };
  // Database callbacks
  databaseCallbacks: {
    onStore: (data: any) => Promise<void>;
    onRetrieve: (id: string) => Promise<any>;
    onError: (error: Error) => Promise<void>;
  };
  // Reporting callbacks
  reportingCallbacks: {
    onMetrics: (metrics: NotificationMetrics) => Promise<void>;
    onAnalytics: (event: string, data: any) => Promise<void>;
  };
 }
 ```
 #### **Callback Registration**
 ```typescript
 interface CallbackRegistry {
  registerCallback(type: CallbackType, callback: Function): void;
  unregisterCallback(type: CallbackType, id: string): void;
  executeCallback(type: CallbackType, data: any): Promise<void>;
  validateCallback(callback: Function): boolean;
 }
 ```
 ---
 ## 🔧 **IMPLEMENTATION APPROACH**
 ### **Phase 1: Interface Updates**
 **Estimated Effort**: 4-6 hours
 1. **Extend existing interfaces**
   ```typescript
   interface NotificationOptions {
     // Existing properties...
     // New callback properties
     apiCallbacks?: APICallbacks;
     databaseCallbacks?: DatabaseCallbacks;
     reportingCallbacks?: ReportingCallbacks;
   }
   ```
 2. **Create new scheduling interfaces**
   ```typescript
   interface ContentFetchOptions {
     url: string;
     apiCallbacks: APICallbacks;
     databaseCallbacks: DatabaseCallbacks;
     retryConfig: RetryConfig;
   }
   interface UserNotificationOptions {
     contentId: string;
     notificationCallbacks: NotificationCallbacks;
     userInteractionCallbacks: UserInteractionCallbacks;
   }
   ```
 ### **Phase 2: Core Implementation**
 **Estimated Effort**: 12-16 hours
 1. **Implement callback registry system**
   - Callback registration and validation
   - Execution engine with error handling
   - Lifecycle management
 2. **Create dual scheduling methods**
   - `scheduleContentFetch()` implementation
   - `scheduleUserNotification()` implementation
   - Backward compatibility layer
 3. **Add callback execution logic**
   - API call handling with callbacks
   - Database operation callbacks
   - Reporting service integration
 ### **Phase 3: Platform Integration**
 **Estimated Effort**: 8-12 hours
 1. **Android implementation**
   - WorkManager integration for background tasks
   - Callback execution in native code
   - Database callback support
 2. **iOS implementation**
   - BGTaskScheduler integration
   - Callback handling in Swift
   - Core Data callback support
 3. **Web implementation**
   - Service Worker integration
   - Browser notification callbacks
   - IndexedDB callback support
 ---
 ## 📊 **COMPLEXITY ASSESSMENT**
 ### **Technical Complexity**: 🔴 **HIGH**
 - **Architecture Changes**: Significant interface redesign required
 - **Platform Integration**: Need to implement across Android/iOS/Web
 - **Callback Management**: Complex lifecycle and error handling
 - **Backward Compatibility**: Must maintain existing API functionality
 ### **Business Complexity**: 🟡 **MEDIUM**
 - **User Impact**: Existing users need migration path
 - **Testing Requirements**: Comprehensive callback testing needed
 - **Documentation**: Significant API documentation updates required
 - **Training**: Team needs to understand new callback patterns
 ### **Risk Factors**: 🔴 **HIGH**
 - **Interface Changes**: Breaking changes to existing API
 - **Performance Impact**: Callback overhead on notification delivery
 - **Platform Differences**: Ensuring consistent behavior across platforms
 - **Error Handling**: Complex callback failure scenarios
 ---
 ## 🚀 **RECOMMENDED IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY**
 ### **1. Research & Design Phase (Days 1-2)**
 - [ ] **Complete callback system design**
 - [ ] **Create interface mockups**
 - [ ] **Design migration strategy**
 - [ ] **Plan testing approach**
 ### **2. Core Implementation Phase (Days 2-4)**
 - [ ] **Implement callback registry system**
 - [ ] **Create dual scheduling methods**
 - [ ] **Add callback execution logic**
 - [ ] **Implement error handling**
 ### **3. Platform Integration Phase (Days 4-5)**
 - [ ] **Android callback integration**
 - [ ] **iOS callback integration**
 - [ ] **Web callback integration**
 - [ ] **Cross-platform testing**
 ### **4. Testing & Documentation Phase (Day 5)**
 - [ ] **Comprehensive callback testing**
 - [ ] **Performance validation**
 - [ ] **API documentation updates**
 - [ ] **Migration guide creation**
 ---
 ## 🔒 **SECURITY CONSIDERATIONS**
 ### **Callback Security**
 - **Input Validation**: Validate all callback parameters
 - **Sandboxing**: Execute callbacks in controlled environment
 - **Rate Limiting**: Prevent callback abuse
 - **Authentication**: Validate callback sources
 ### **Data Security**
 - **Encryption**: Encrypt sensitive data in callbacks
 - **Access Control**: Limit callback access to necessary data
 - **Audit Logging**: Log all callback executions
 - **Error Handling**: Prevent information leakage in errors
 ---
 ## 📈 **PERFORMANCE IMPACT**
 ### **Callback Overhead**
 - **Execution Time**: Additional 10-50ms per callback
 - **Memory Usage**: Callback registry storage
 - **Battery Impact**: Minimal on modern devices
 - **Network Impact**: Depends on callback implementation
 ### **Optimization Strategies**
 - **Callback Batching**: Execute multiple callbacks together
 - **Async Execution**: Non-blocking callback execution
 - **Caching**: Cache callback results where appropriate
 - **Lazy Loading**: Load callbacks only when needed
 ---
 ## 🧪 **TESTING STRATEGY**
 ### **Unit Testing**
 - **Callback Registration**: Test callback registration/unregistration
 - **Callback Execution**: Test successful and failed executions
 - **Error Handling**: Test various error scenarios
 - **Performance**: Test callback execution performance
 ### **Integration Testing**
 - **API Integration**: Test with real external services
 - **Database Integration**: Test database callback scenarios
 - **Cross-Platform**: Test consistency across platforms
 - **End-to-End**: Test complete notification flow
 ### **Performance Testing**
 - **Callback Latency**: Measure callback execution time
 - **Memory Usage**: Monitor memory impact of callbacks
 - **Battery Impact**: Test battery usage with callbacks
 - **Scalability**: Test with multiple concurrent callbacks
 ---
 ## 📚 **REFERENCES & RESOURCES**
 ### **Design Patterns**
 - **Observer Pattern**: For callback registration and execution
 - **Strategy Pattern**: For different callback execution strategies
 - **Factory Pattern**: For creating different callback types
 - **Chain of Responsibility**: For callback execution flow
 ### **Platform-Specific Resources**
 - **Android**: WorkManager, AlarmManager, Room database
 - **iOS**: BGTaskScheduler, UNCalendarNotificationTrigger, Core Data
 - **Web**: Service Workers, IndexedDB, Browser Notifications API
 ### **Best Practices**
 - **Error Handling**: Comprehensive error handling for callbacks
 - **Performance**: Optimize callback execution for mobile devices
 - **Security**: Secure callback execution and data handling
 - **Testing**: Thorough testing of callback scenarios
 ---
 **Next Steps**: Complete callback system design and create implementation plan  
 **Estimated Timeline**: 3-5 days for full implementation  
 **Success Criteria**: Dual scheduling methods working with full callback support  
 **Risk Level**: 🔴 **HIGH** - Requires careful planning and implementation