Browse Source
Migrate automatic identity creation from scattered view components to centralized router navigation guard for consistent behavior across all entry points. **Key Changes:** - Add global beforeEach navigation guard in router/index.ts - Remove automatic identity creation from HomeView, ContactsView, InviteOneAcceptView, and OnboardMeetingMembersView - Keep minimal fallback logic in deep link scenarios with logging - Exclude manual identity creation routes (/start, /new-identifier, /import-account) **Benefits:** - Eliminates code duplication and race conditions - Ensures consistent identity creation regardless of entry point - Centralizes error handling with fallback to manual creation - Improves maintainability with single point of change **Files Modified:** - src/router/index.ts: Add navigation guard with identity creation logic - src/views/HomeView.vue: Remove automatic creation, simplify initializeIdentity() - src/views/ContactsView.vue: Add fallback with logging - src/views/InviteOneAcceptView.vue: Add fallback with logging - src/views/OnboardMeetingMembersView.vue: Add fallback with logging **Testing:** - Verified first-time user navigation creates identity automatically - Confirmed existing users bypass creation logic - Validated manual creation routes remain unaffected - Tested deep link scenarios with fallback logic **Documentation:** - Created docs/identity-creation-migration.md with comprehensive details - Includes migration rationale, implementation details, testing scenarios - Documents security considerations and rollback plan Resolves inconsistent identity creation behavior across different app entry points.pull/142/head
Matthew Raymer
1 week ago
15 changed files with 1121 additions and 99 deletions
@ -0,0 +1,189 @@ |
|||
# Identity Creation Migration |
|||
|
|||
## Overview |
|||
|
|||
This document describes the migration of automatic identity creation from individual view components to a centralized router navigation guard. This change ensures that user identities are created consistently regardless of entry point, improving the user experience and reducing code duplication. |
|||
|
|||
## Problem Statement |
|||
|
|||
Previously, automatic identity creation was scattered across multiple view components: |
|||
- `HomeView.vue` - Primary entry point |
|||
- `InviteOneAcceptView.vue` - Deep link entry point |
|||
- `ContactsView.vue` - Contact management |
|||
- `OnboardMeetingMembersView.vue` - Meeting setup |
|||
|
|||
This approach had several issues: |
|||
1. **Inconsistent behavior** - Different entry points could have different identity creation logic |
|||
2. **Code duplication** - Similar identity creation code repeated across multiple components |
|||
3. **Race conditions** - Multiple components could attempt identity creation simultaneously |
|||
4. **Maintenance overhead** - Changes to identity creation required updates in multiple files |
|||
|
|||
## Solution: Router Navigation Guard |
|||
|
|||
### Implementation |
|||
|
|||
The solution moves identity creation to a global router navigation guard in `src/router/index.ts`: |
|||
|
|||
```typescript |
|||
router.beforeEach(async (to, from, next) => { |
|||
try { |
|||
// Skip identity check for certain routes |
|||
const skipIdentityRoutes = ['/start', '/new-identifier', '/import-account', '/database-migration']; |
|||
if (skipIdentityRoutes.includes(to.path)) { |
|||
return next(); |
|||
} |
|||
|
|||
// Check if user has any identities |
|||
const allMyDids = await retrieveAccountDids(); |
|||
|
|||
// Create identity if none exists |
|||
if (allMyDids.length === 0) { |
|||
logger.info("[Router] No identities found, creating default seed-based identity"); |
|||
await generateSaveAndActivateIdentity(); |
|||
} |
|||
|
|||
next(); |
|||
} catch (error) { |
|||
logger.error("[Router] Identity creation failed:", error); |
|||
next('/start'); // Redirect to manual identity creation |
|||
} |
|||
}); |
|||
``` |
|||
|
|||
### Benefits |
|||
|
|||
1. **Centralized Logic** - All identity creation happens in one place |
|||
2. **Consistent Behavior** - Same identity creation process regardless of entry point |
|||
3. **Early Execution** - Identity creation happens before any view loads |
|||
4. **Error Handling** - Centralized error handling with fallback to manual creation |
|||
5. **Maintainability** - Single point of change for identity creation logic |
|||
|
|||
## Migration Details |
|||
|
|||
### Files Modified |
|||
|
|||
1. **`src/router/index.ts`** |
|||
- Added global `beforeEach` navigation guard |
|||
- Added identity creation logic with error handling |
|||
- Added route exclusions for manual identity creation |
|||
|
|||
2. **`src/views/HomeView.vue`** |
|||
- Removed automatic identity creation logic |
|||
- Removed `isCreatingIdentifier` state and UI |
|||
- Simplified `initializeIdentity()` method |
|||
- Added fallback error handling |
|||
|
|||
3. **`src/views/InviteOneAcceptView.vue`** |
|||
- Kept identity creation as fallback for deep links |
|||
- Added logging for fallback scenarios |
|||
- Simplified logic since router guard handles most cases |
|||
|
|||
4. **`src/views/ContactsView.vue`** |
|||
- Kept identity creation as fallback for invite processing |
|||
- Added logging for fallback scenarios |
|||
- Simplified logic since router guard handles most cases |
|||
|
|||
5. **`src/views/OnboardMeetingMembersView.vue`** |
|||
- Kept identity creation as fallback for meeting setup |
|||
- Added logging for fallback scenarios |
|||
- Simplified logic since router guard handles most cases |
|||
|
|||
### Route Exclusions |
|||
|
|||
The following routes are excluded from automatic identity creation: |
|||
- `/start` - Manual identity creation selection |
|||
- `/new-identifier` - Manual seed-based identity creation |
|||
- `/import-account` - Manual account import |
|||
- `/database-migration` - Database migration process |
|||
|
|||
### Fallback Strategy |
|||
|
|||
For deep link scenarios and edge cases, individual views retain minimal identity creation logic as fallbacks: |
|||
- Only triggers if `activeDid` is missing |
|||
- Includes logging to identify when fallbacks are used |
|||
- Maintains backward compatibility |
|||
|
|||
## Testing Considerations |
|||
|
|||
### Test Scenarios |
|||
|
|||
1. **First-time user navigation** |
|||
- Navigate to any route without existing identity |
|||
- Verify automatic identity creation |
|||
- Verify proper navigation to intended route |
|||
|
|||
2. **Existing user navigation** |
|||
- Navigate to any route with existing identity |
|||
- Verify no unnecessary identity creation |
|||
- Verify normal navigation flow |
|||
|
|||
3. **Manual identity creation routes** |
|||
- Navigate to `/start`, `/new-identifier`, `/import-account` |
|||
- Verify no automatic identity creation |
|||
- Verify manual creation flow works |
|||
|
|||
4. **Error scenarios** |
|||
- Simulate identity creation failure |
|||
- Verify fallback to `/start` route |
|||
- Verify error logging |
|||
|
|||
5. **Deep link scenarios** |
|||
- Test invite acceptance without existing identity |
|||
- Verify fallback identity creation works |
|||
- Verify proper invite processing |
|||
|
|||
### Performance Impact |
|||
|
|||
- **Positive**: Reduced code duplication and simplified view logic |
|||
- **Minimal**: Router guard adds negligible overhead |
|||
- **Improved**: Consistent identity creation timing |
|||
|
|||
## Security Considerations |
|||
|
|||
### Privacy Preservation |
|||
- Identity creation still uses the same secure seed generation |
|||
- No changes to cryptographic implementation |
|||
- Maintains user privacy and data sovereignty |
|||
|
|||
### Error Handling |
|||
- Centralized error handling prevents identity creation failures from breaking the app |
|||
- Fallback to manual creation ensures users can always create identities |
|||
- Proper logging for debugging and monitoring |
|||
|
|||
## Future Enhancements |
|||
|
|||
### Potential Improvements |
|||
|
|||
1. **Identity Type Selection** |
|||
- Allow users to choose identity type during automatic creation |
|||
- Support for different identity creation methods |
|||
|
|||
2. **Progressive Enhancement** |
|||
- Add identity creation progress indicators |
|||
- Improve user feedback during creation process |
|||
|
|||
3. **Advanced Fallbacks** |
|||
- Implement more sophisticated fallback strategies |
|||
- Add retry logic for failed identity creation |
|||
|
|||
4. **Analytics Integration** |
|||
- Track identity creation success rates |
|||
- Monitor fallback usage patterns |
|||
|
|||
## Rollback Plan |
|||
|
|||
If issues arise, the migration can be rolled back by: |
|||
|
|||
1. Removing the router navigation guard from `src/router/index.ts` |
|||
2. Restoring automatic identity creation in individual views |
|||
3. Reverting to the previous implementation pattern |
|||
|
|||
## Conclusion |
|||
|
|||
This migration successfully centralizes identity creation logic while maintaining backward compatibility and improving the overall user experience. The router navigation guard approach provides a robust, maintainable solution that ensures consistent identity creation across all entry points. |
|||
|
|||
## Related Documentation |
|||
|
|||
- [Database Migration Guide](../doc/database-migration-guide.md) |
|||
- [Migration Progress Tracker](../doc/migration-progress-tracker.md) |
|||
- [Platform Service Architecture](../doc/platformservicemixin-completion-plan.md) |
|||
@ -0,0 +1,112 @@ |
|||
# Corrected Migration Assessment - Critical Files Analysis |
|||
|
|||
**Date**: 2025-7 |
|||
**Analysis Method**: Direct file inspection using grep and file reading tools |
|||
**Purpose**: Verify our initial assessment and identify actual issues vs false positives |
|||
|
|||
## Executive Summary |
|||
|
|||
After direct analysis of the critical files identified in our initial assessment, I found that **our evaluation was mostly accurate** but with some important corrections. The merge did preserve most migration infrastructure, but several components have legitimate incomplete migrations. |
|||
|
|||
## Detailed Analysis Results |
|||
|
|||
### 1 **MembersList.vue** - ✅ **CORRECTLY IDENTIFIED ISSUE** |
|||
|
|||
**Status**: Mixed pattern - Incomplete notification migration |
|||
**Issues Found**: |
|||
- ✅ **No legacy patterns**: No databaseUtil, logConsoleAndDb, or PlatformServiceFactory usage |
|||
- ✅ **PlatformServiceMixin**: Properly integrated and used |
|||
- ❌ **Notification Migration**:2direct `$notify()` calls remain (lines380, 395) |
|||
- ⚠️ **TODO Comment**: Has migration TODO comment indicating incomplete work |
|||
|
|||
**Analysis**: The2remaining `$notify()` calls are **legitimate complex modal dialogs** that cannot be easily converted to helper methods due to: |
|||
- Nested callbacks (`onYes`, `onNo`, `onCancel`) |
|||
- Complex confirmation flow logic |
|||
- Custom button text and behavior |
|||
|
|||
**Verdict**: This is a **true incomplete migration** that requires attention. |
|||
|
|||
###2. **ContactsView.vue** - ✅ **CORRECTLY IDENTIFIED ISSUE** |
|||
|
|||
**Status**: Mixed pattern - Incomplete notification migration |
|||
**Issues Found**: |
|||
- ✅ **No legacy patterns**: No databaseUtil, logConsoleAndDb, or PlatformServiceFactory usage |
|||
- ✅ **PlatformServiceMixin**: Properly integrated and used |
|||
- ❌ **Notification Migration**:4direct `$notify()` calls remain (lines 410 83210031208- ✅ **Helper Setup**: Has `createNotifyHelpers` setup |
|||
|
|||
**Analysis**: The4remaining `$notify()` calls appear to be complex modal dialogs that need migration. |
|||
|
|||
**Verdict**: This is a **true incomplete migration** that requires attention. |
|||
|
|||
### 3. **OnboardMeetingSetupView.vue** - ❌ **FALSE POSITIVE** |
|||
|
|||
**Status**: ✅ **FULLY MIGRATED** |
|||
**Issues Found**: |
|||
- ✅ **No legacy patterns**: No databaseUtil, logConsoleAndDb, or PlatformServiceFactory usage |
|||
- ✅ **PlatformServiceMixin**: Properly integrated and used |
|||
- ✅ **Notification Migration**: Only has helper setup, no direct `$notify()` calls |
|||
- ✅ **Helper Setup**: Has `createNotifyHelpers` setup |
|||
|
|||
**Analysis**: This file only has the helper setup line (`this.notify = createNotifyHelpers(this.$notify as any);`) but no actual `$notify()` calls. |
|||
|
|||
**Verdict**: This is a **false positive** - the file is fully migrated. |
|||
|
|||
###4 **databaseUtil.ts** - ✅ **CORRECTLY IDENTIFIED ISSUE** |
|||
|
|||
**Status**: Legacy logging patterns remain |
|||
**Issues Found**: |
|||
- ❌ **Legacy Logging**: 15+ `logConsoleAndDb()` calls throughout the file |
|||
- ✅ **Function Definition**: Contains the `logConsoleAndDb` function definition |
|||
- ⚠️ **Migration Status**: This file is intentionally kept for backward compatibility |
|||
|
|||
**Analysis**: This file contains the legacy logging function and its usage, which is expected during migration. |
|||
|
|||
**Verdict**: This is a **legitimate legacy pattern** that should be addressed in the final cleanup phase. |
|||
|
|||
###5. **index.ts** - ❓ **NEEDS VERIFICATION** |
|||
|
|||
**Status**: Not analyzed in detail |
|||
**Note**: This file was mentioned in the initial assessment but needs individual analysis. |
|||
|
|||
## Corrected Assessment Summary |
|||
|
|||
### **True Issues Found (3 files)**: |
|||
1 **MembersList.vue** -2direct `$notify()` calls need migration2. **ContactsView.vue** -4direct `$notify()` calls need migration 3 **databaseUtil.ts** - Legacy logging patterns (expected during migration) |
|||
|
|||
### **false Positives (1e)**: |
|||
1. **OnboardMeetingSetupView.vue** - Fully migrated, no issues |
|||
|
|||
### **Not Analyzed (1 file)**:1index.ts** - Needs individual analysis |
|||
|
|||
## Impact on Initial Assessment |
|||
|
|||
### **Accuracy**:753ed files correctly identified) |
|||
- **Correctly Identified**: MembersList.vue, ContactsView.vue, databaseUtil.ts |
|||
- **False Positive**: OnboardMeetingSetupView.vue |
|||
|
|||
### **Severity Adjustment**: |
|||
- **Critical Issues**: Reduced from3to 2 **Legacy Patterns**: Confirmed in databaseUtil.ts (expected) |
|||
- **Overall Impact**: Less severe than initially assessed |
|||
|
|||
## Recommendations |
|||
|
|||
### **Immediate Actions**: |
|||
1. **Complete notification migration** for MembersList.vue (2 calls) |
|||
2. **Complete notification migration** for ContactsView.vue (4 calls) |
|||
3**Analyze index.ts** to determine if it has issues |
|||
|
|||
### **Tool Improvements**: |
|||
1. **Enhanced validation script** should exclude helper setup lines from `$notify()` detection |
|||
2. **Better pattern matching** to distinguish between helper setup and actual usage |
|||
3ext-aware analysis** to identify legitimate complex modal dialogs |
|||
|
|||
### **Migration Strategy**: |
|||
1. **Focus on the2omplete migrations** |
|||
2. **Consider complex modal dialogs** as legitimate exceptions to helper migration |
|||
3*Plan databaseUtil.ts cleanup** for final migration phase |
|||
|
|||
## Conclusion |
|||
|
|||
Our initial assessment was **mostly accurate** but had one false positive. The merge did preserve migration infrastructure well, with only 2 components having legitimate incomplete notification migrations. The issues are less severe than initially thought, but still require attention to complete the migration properly. |
|||
|
|||
**Next Steps**: Focus on completing the2plete notification migrations and improving our validation tools to reduce false positives. |
|||
@ -0,0 +1,274 @@ |
|||
# True Issues Analysis - Detailed Breakdown |
|||
|
|||
**Date**: 2025-7 |
|||
**Analysis Method**: Direct file inspection and code review |
|||
**Purpose**: Provide detailed analysis of each true issue identified |
|||
|
|||
## Executive Summary |
|||
|
|||
After systematic analysis of each identified issue, I found that **2 components have legitimate incomplete notification migrations** and **2 files have expected legacy logging patterns**. The issues are less severe than initially assessed, with most being either legitimate complex modal dialogs or expected legacy patterns during migration. |
|||
|
|||
## Issue 1 MembersList.vue - Complex Modal Dialogs |
|||
|
|||
### **Status**: ✅ **LEGITIMATE COMPLEX MODAL** - No Action Required |
|||
|
|||
**Location**: Lines 380395 |
|||
**Issue Type**: Direct `$notify()` calls in complex modal dialogs |
|||
|
|||
### **Detailed Analysis**: |
|||
|
|||
#### **First Modal (Line 380)**: |
|||
```typescript |
|||
this.$notify({ |
|||
group: modal, |
|||
type: confirm, |
|||
title: NOTIFY_ADD_CONTACT_FIRST.title, |
|||
text: NOTIFY_ADD_CONTACT_FIRST.text, |
|||
yesText: NOTIFY_ADD_CONTACT_FIRST.yesText, |
|||
noText: NOTIFY_ADD_CONTACT_FIRST.noText, |
|||
onYes: async () => { |
|||
await this.addAsContact(decrMember); |
|||
await this.toggleAdmission(decrMember); |
|||
}, |
|||
onNo: async () => { |
|||
// Nested modal call |
|||
this.$notify({...}); |
|||
}, |
|||
}, TIMEOUTS.MODAL); |
|||
``` |
|||
|
|||
#### **Second Modal (Line 395)**: |
|||
```typescript |
|||
this.$notify({ |
|||
group: modal, |
|||
type: confirm,title: NOTIFY_CONTINUE_WITHOUT_ADDING.title, |
|||
text: NOTIFY_CONTINUE_WITHOUT_ADDING.text, |
|||
yesText: NOTIFY_CONTINUE_WITHOUT_ADDING.yesText, |
|||
onYes: async () => [object Object] await this.toggleAdmission(decrMember); |
|||
}, |
|||
onCancel: async () => { |
|||
// Do nothing, effectively canceling the operation |
|||
}, |
|||
}, TIMEOUTS.MODAL); |
|||
``` |
|||
|
|||
### **Why These Are Legitimate**:1**Nested Callbacks**: The first modal has an `onNo` callback that triggers a second modal2Complex Flow Logic**: The modals implement a multi-step confirmation process |
|||
3Custom Button Text**: Uses constants but with custom `yesText`, `noText` properties |
|||
4. **Async Operations**: Both callbacks perform async operations (`addAsContact`, `toggleAdmission`) |
|||
5. **State Management**: The modals manage complex state transitions |
|||
|
|||
### **Migration Assessment**: ❌ **NOT RECOMMENDED** |
|||
|
|||
These modals cannot be easily converted to helper methods because: |
|||
- Helper methods don't support nested callbacks |
|||
- The complex flow logic requires custom modal configuration |
|||
- The async operations in callbacks need custom handling |
|||
|
|||
### **Recommendation**: ✅ **KEEP AS IS** |
|||
|
|||
These are legitimate complex modal dialogs that should remain as raw `$notify()` calls. They already use notification constants and follow best practices. |
|||
|
|||
--- |
|||
|
|||
## Issue2: ContactsView.vue - Mixed Notification Patterns |
|||
|
|||
### **Status**: ⚠️ **INCOMPLETE MIGRATION** - Action Required |
|||
|
|||
**Location**: Lines 4108323208 |
|||
**Issue Type**: Direct `$notify()` calls that can be migrated |
|||
|
|||
### **Detailed Analysis**: |
|||
|
|||
#### **Modal 1 (Line 410imple Confirmation**: |
|||
```typescript |
|||
this.$notify({ |
|||
group: modal, |
|||
type: confirm", |
|||
title:They're Added To Your List", |
|||
text: Would you like to go to the main page now?", |
|||
onYes: async () => [object Object] this.$router.push({ name: home" }); |
|||
}, |
|||
}, -1); |
|||
``` |
|||
|
|||
**Migration Potential**: ✅ **EASY** - Simple confirmation with single callback |
|||
|
|||
#### **Modal 2 (Line 832egistration Prompt**: |
|||
```typescript |
|||
this.$notify({ |
|||
group: modal, |
|||
type: confirm", |
|||
title: Register,text: "Do you want to register them?", |
|||
onCancel: async (stopAsking?: boolean) => { |
|||
await this.handleRegistrationPromptResponse(stopAsking); |
|||
}, |
|||
onNo: async (stopAsking?: boolean) => { |
|||
await this.handleRegistrationPromptResponse(stopAsking); |
|||
}, |
|||
onYes: async () => { |
|||
await this.register(newContact); |
|||
}, |
|||
promptToStopAsking: true, |
|||
}, -1); |
|||
``` |
|||
|
|||
**Migration Potential**: ⚠️ **COMPLEX** - Has `promptToStopAsking` and multiple callbacks |
|||
|
|||
#### **Modal 33 Unconfirmed Hours Warning**: |
|||
```typescript |
|||
this.$notify({ |
|||
group: modal, |
|||
type: confirm", |
|||
title:Delete, |
|||
text: message, // Dynamic message about unconfirmed hours |
|||
onNo: async () => { |
|||
this.showGiftedDialog(giverDid, recipientDid); |
|||
}, |
|||
onYes: async () => [object Object] this.$router.push({ |
|||
name: "contact-amounts", |
|||
query: { contactDid: giverDid }, |
|||
}); |
|||
}, |
|||
}, -1); |
|||
``` |
|||
|
|||
**Migration Potential**: ⚠️ **COMPLEX** - Dynamic message generation |
|||
|
|||
#### **Modal 41208Onboarding Meeting**: |
|||
```typescript |
|||
this.$notify({ |
|||
group: modal, |
|||
type: confirm", |
|||
title: "Onboarding Meeting", |
|||
text: Would you like to start a new meeting?", |
|||
onYes: async () => [object Object] this.$router.push({ name: "onboard-meeting-setup" }); |
|||
}, |
|||
yesText: Start New Meeting", |
|||
onNo: async () => [object Object] this.$router.push({ name: "onboard-meeting-list" }); |
|||
}, |
|||
noText: "Join Existing Meeting, |
|||
}, -1); |
|||
``` |
|||
|
|||
**Migration Potential**: ⚠️ **COMPLEX** - Custom button text |
|||
|
|||
### **Migration Strategy**: |
|||
1 **Modal 1**: ✅ **Easy migration** - Convert to `this.notify.confirm()`2 **Modal 2**: ❌ **Keep as is** - Complex with `promptToStopAsking`3 **Modal 3**: ❌ **Keep as is** - Dynamic message generation4 **Modal 4**: ❌ **Keep as is** - Custom button text |
|||
|
|||
### **Recommendation**: ⚠️ **PARTIAL MIGRATION** |
|||
|
|||
Only Modal 1 can be easily migrated. The others are legitimate complex modals. |
|||
|
|||
--- |
|||
|
|||
## Issue 3 databaseUtil.ts - Legacy Logging Patterns |
|||
|
|||
### **Status**: ✅ **EXPECTED LEGACY PATTERN** - No Action Required |
|||
|
|||
**Location**: Throughout the file |
|||
**Issue Type**: 15+ `logConsoleAndDb()` calls |
|||
|
|||
### **Detailed Analysis**: |
|||
|
|||
#### **Function Definition (Line 325)**: |
|||
```typescript |
|||
export async function logConsoleAndDb( |
|||
message: string, |
|||
isError = false, |
|||
): Promise<void> { |
|||
if (isError) { |
|||
logger.error(message); |
|||
} else { |
|||
logger.log(message); |
|||
} |
|||
await logToDb(message, isError ? "error" : "info); |
|||
} |
|||
``` |
|||
|
|||
#### **Usage Examples**: |
|||
- Line 235: Error logging in `retrieveSettingsForActiveAccount()` |
|||
- Line 502: Debug logging in `debugSettingsData()` |
|||
- Line51059e debug statements |
|||
|
|||
### **Why This Is Expected**: |
|||
|
|||
1. **Migration Phase**: This file is intentionally kept during migration for backward compatibility |
|||
2. **Function Definition**: Contains the legacy function that other files may still use |
|||
3. **Debug Functions**: Many calls are in debug/development functions |
|||
4. **Gradual Migration**: This will be cleaned up in the final migration phase |
|||
|
|||
### **Migration Assessment**: ✅ **PLANNED FOR CLEANUP** |
|||
|
|||
This is expected during the migration process and will be addressed in the final cleanup phase. |
|||
|
|||
### **Recommendation**: ✅ **KEEP AS IS** - Address in final cleanup |
|||
|
|||
--- |
|||
|
|||
## Issue 4: index.ts - Legacy Logging Pattern |
|||
|
|||
### **Status**: ✅ **EXPECTED LEGACY PATTERN** - No Action Required |
|||
|
|||
**Location**: Line 240 |
|||
**Issue Type**: 1logConsoleAndDb()` call |
|||
|
|||
### **Detailed Analysis**: |
|||
|
|||
#### **Usage (Line 240)**: |
|||
```typescript |
|||
logConsoleAndDb("Error processing secret & encrypted accountsDB.", error); |
|||
``` |
|||
|
|||
#### **Function Export (Line 305)**: |
|||
```typescript |
|||
export async function logConsoleAndDb( |
|||
``` |
|||
|
|||
### **Why This Is Expected**: |
|||
|
|||
1. **Database Module**: This file is part of the database module thats being migrated |
|||
2. **Error Handling**: The call is in error handling code |
|||
3. **Consistent Pattern**: Follows the same pattern as databaseUtil.ts |
|||
|
|||
### **Migration Assessment**: ✅ **PLANNED FOR CLEANUP** |
|||
|
|||
This will be addressed when the database module migration is completed. |
|||
|
|||
### **Recommendation**: ✅ **KEEP AS IS** - Address in final cleanup |
|||
|
|||
--- |
|||
|
|||
## Summary of True Issues |
|||
|
|||
### **Issues Requiring Action (1)**:1. **ContactsView.vue Modal 1** - Simple confirmation dialog (easy migration) |
|||
|
|||
### **Issues That Are Legitimate (3: |
|||
1 **MembersList.vue** - Complex modal dialogs (keep as is)2. **ContactsView.vue Modals 2-4* - Complex modals (keep as is)3 **databaseUtil.ts** - Expected legacy patterns (cleanup phase)4ex.ts** - Expected legacy patterns (cleanup phase) |
|||
|
|||
### **Impact Assessment**: |
|||
- **Actual Migration Work**: 1 simple modal conversion |
|||
- **False Positives**:3t of 4 issues were legitimate |
|||
- **Overall Severity**: Much lower than initially assessed |
|||
|
|||
## Recommendations |
|||
|
|||
### **Immediate Actions**: |
|||
1. **Migrate ContactsView.vue Modal 1** to use `this.notify.confirm()` |
|||
2. **Update validation scripts** to better identify legitimate complex modals |
|||
3. **Document complex modal patterns** for future reference |
|||
|
|||
### **Tool Improvements**: |
|||
1. **Enhanced detection** for complex modal patterns |
|||
2ext-aware analysis** to distinguish legitimate vs incomplete migrations |
|||
3. **Better documentation** of migration exceptions |
|||
|
|||
### **Migration Strategy**: |
|||
1. **Focus on simple migrations** that can be easily converted |
|||
2. **Accept complex modals** as legitimate exceptions |
|||
3. **Plan legacy cleanup** for final migration phase |
|||
|
|||
## Conclusion |
|||
|
|||
The merge was **highly successful** in preserving migration infrastructure. Only 1 out of 4 identified issues actually requires migration work. The remaining issues are either legitimate complex modal dialogs or expected legacy patterns during the migration process. |
|||
|
|||
**Next Steps**: Complete the single simple modal migration and improve validation tools to reduce false positives in future assessments. |
|||
@ -0,0 +1,145 @@ |
|||
#!/bin/bash |
|||
|
|||
# Enhanced Migration Validator for TimeSafari |
|||
# Provides detailed analysis of migration status with improved accuracy |
|||
|
|||
echo 🔍 Enhanced TimeSafari Migration Validator" |
|||
echo "========================================== |
|||
echo [$(date +%Y-%m-%d\ %H:%M:%S)] Starting enhanced validation..." |
|||
|
|||
# Function to check if file has actual legacy patterns (not just in comments) |
|||
check_legacy_patterns() { |
|||
local file="$1" |
|||
local pattern="$2" |
|||
local description="$3 |
|||
# Check for actual usage (excluding comments and strings) |
|||
local count=$(grep -v ^[[:space:]]*//\|^[[:space:]]*\*\|^[[:space:]]*<!--" "$file" | \ |
|||
grep -v TODO.*migration\|FIXME.*migration" | \ |
|||
grep -v "Migration.*replaced\|migrated.*from" | \ |
|||
grep -c $pattern" || echo 0) |
|||
|
|||
if [$count" -gt0 then |
|||
echo ❌ $description: $count instances |
|||
return 1 else |
|||
echo ✅$description: None found |
|||
return 0 |
|||
fi |
|||
} |
|||
|
|||
# Function to check notification migration status |
|||
check_notification_migration() { |
|||
local file="$1 |
|||
# Check if file has notification helpers setup |
|||
local has_helpers=$(grep -c "createNotifyHelpers" $file" || echo "0") |
|||
|
|||
# Check for direct $notify calls (excluding helper setup) |
|||
local direct_notify=$(grep -v "createNotifyHelpers" "$file" | \ |
|||
grep -v this\.notify\." | \ |
|||
grep -c "this\.\$notify" || echo "0") |
|||
|
|||
# Check for helper usage |
|||
local helper_usage=$(grep -c "this\.notify\." $file" || echo 0) |
|||
|
|||
if $has_helpers" -gt0 && $direct_notify" -eq0 then |
|||
echo " ✅ Complete notification migration |
|||
return 0 |
|||
elif $has_helpers" -gt0 && $direct_notify" -gt0 then |
|||
echo " ⚠️ Mixed pattern: $direct_notify direct calls, $helper_usage helper calls |
|||
return 1 |
|||
elif $has_helpers" -gt 0&$helper_usage" -eq0 then |
|||
echo " ⚠️ Unused helper setup |
|||
return 1 else |
|||
echo " ❌ No notification migration |
|||
return 1 |
|||
fi |
|||
} |
|||
|
|||
# Function to check PlatformServiceMixin usage |
|||
check_mixin_usage() { |
|||
local file="$1 |
|||
# Check for mixin import |
|||
local has_import=$(grep -cPlatformServiceMixin" $file" || echo "0") |
|||
|
|||
# Check for mixin in component definition |
|||
local has_mixin=$(grep -cmixins.*PlatformServiceMixin\|mixins.*\[PlatformServiceMixin" $file" || echo "0") |
|||
|
|||
# Check for mixin method usage |
|||
local method_usage=$(grep -c this\.\$$file | grep -E "(get|insert|update|delete|log|settings|contacts)" || echo 0) |
|||
|
|||
if $has_import" -gt 0 ] && $has_mixin" -gt0 then |
|||
echo " ✅ PlatformServiceMixin properly integrated |
|||
return 0 |
|||
elif $has_import" -gt 0 ] && $has_mixin" -eq0 then |
|||
echo " ⚠️ Imported but not used as mixin |
|||
return 1 else |
|||
echo " ❌ No PlatformServiceMixin usage |
|||
return 1 |
|||
fi |
|||
} |
|||
|
|||
# Function to analyze a specific file |
|||
analyze_file() { |
|||
local file="$1 echo "" |
|||
echo "📄 Analyzing: $file" |
|||
echo "----------------------------------------" |
|||
|
|||
local issues=0 # Check legacy patterns |
|||
echo 🔍 Legacy Pattern Analysis: |
|||
check_legacy_patterns$file aseUtil" "databaseUtil usage || ((issues++)) |
|||
check_legacy_patterns "$filelogConsoleAndDb ConsoleAndDb usage || ((issues++)) |
|||
check_legacy_patterns$file formServiceFactory\.getInstance ct PlatformService usage ||((issues++)) |
|||
|
|||
# Check notification migration |
|||
echo "🔔 Notification Migration:" |
|||
check_notification_migration "$file ||((issues++)) |
|||
|
|||
# Check PlatformServiceMixin usage |
|||
echo "🔧 PlatformServiceMixin: check_mixin_usage "$file ||((issues++)) |
|||
|
|||
# Check for TODO comments indicating incomplete work |
|||
local todo_count=$(grep -c TODO.*migration\|FIXME.*migration" $file || echo "0) if $todo_count" -gt0 then |
|||
echo ⚠️ TODO/FIXME comments: $todo_count ((issues++)) |
|||
fi |
|||
|
|||
if$issues" -eq0 then |
|||
echo "✅ File is fully migrated else |
|||
echo❌ $issues issues found" |
|||
fi |
|||
|
|||
return $issues |
|||
} |
|||
|
|||
# Main analysis |
|||
echo "" |
|||
echo "📊 Enhanced Migration Analysis" |
|||
echo "==============================" |
|||
|
|||
# Analyze critical files identified in the assessment |
|||
critical_files=( |
|||
src/components/MembersList.vue" |
|||
"src/views/ContactsView.vue" |
|||
src/views/OnboardMeetingSetupView.vue" |
|||
src/db/databaseUtil.ts" |
|||
src/db/index.ts |
|||
) |
|||
|
|||
total_issues=0 |
|||
for file in${critical_files[@]}"; do |
|||
if [ -f "$file" ]; then |
|||
analyze_file "$file" |
|||
total_issues=$((total_issues + $?)) |
|||
else |
|||
echo ❌ File not found: $file" |
|||
fi |
|||
done |
|||
|
|||
# Summary |
|||
echo "echo📋 Summary" |
|||
echo==========" |
|||
echo "Critical files analyzed: ${#critical_files[@]}" |
|||
echo "Total issues found: $total_issues" |
|||
|
|||
if$total_issues" -eq 0]; then |
|||
echo "✅ All critical files are properly migrated exit 0 echo "❌ Migration issues require attention" |
|||
exit 1 |
|||
fi |
|||
@ -0,0 +1,122 @@ |
|||
#!/bin/bash |
|||
|
|||
echo "🔍 Simple Migration Validator" |
|||
echo "=============================" |
|||
|
|||
# Function to check actual usage (not comments) |
|||
check_actual_usage() { |
|||
local file="$1" |
|||
local pattern="$2" |
|||
local description="$3" |
|||
|
|||
# Remove comments and check for actual usage |
|||
local count=$(grep -v ^[[:space:]]*//\|^[[:space:]]*\*\|^[[:space:]]*<!--" "$file" | \ |
|||
grep -v TODO.*migration\|FIXME.*migration" | \ |
|||
grep -v "Migration.*replaced\|migrated.*from" | \ |
|||
grep -c $pattern" || echo 0) |
|||
|
|||
if [$count" -gt0 then |
|||
echo ❌ $description: $count instances |
|||
return 1 else |
|||
echo ✅$description: None found |
|||
return 0 |
|||
fi |
|||
} |
|||
|
|||
# Function to check notification migration |
|||
check_notifications() { |
|||
local file="$1 |
|||
# Check for notification helpers |
|||
local has_helpers=$(grep -c "createNotifyHelpers" $file" || echo "0") |
|||
|
|||
# Check for direct $notify calls (excluding helper setup) |
|||
local direct_notify=$(grep -v "createNotifyHelpers" "$file" | \ |
|||
grep -v this\.notify\." | \ |
|||
grep -c "this\.\$notify" || echo 0) |
|||
|
|||
if $has_helpers" -gt0 && $direct_notify" -eq0 then |
|||
echo " ✅ Complete notification migration |
|||
return 0 |
|||
elif $has_helpers" -gt0 && $direct_notify" -gt0 then |
|||
echo " ⚠️ Mixed pattern: $direct_notify direct calls |
|||
return 1 else |
|||
echo " ❌ No notification migration |
|||
return 1 |
|||
fi |
|||
} |
|||
|
|||
# Function to analyze a file |
|||
analyze_file() { |
|||
local file="$1 echo "" |
|||
echo "📄 Analyzing: $file" |
|||
echo "----------------------------------------" |
|||
|
|||
local issues=0 # Check legacy patterns |
|||
echo "🔍 Legacy Patterns: |
|||
check_actual_usage$file aseUtil" "databaseUtil usage || ((issues++)) |
|||
check_actual_usage "$filelogConsoleAndDb ConsoleAndDb usage || ((issues++)) |
|||
check_actual_usage$file formServiceFactory\.getInstance ct PlatformService usage ||((issues++)) |
|||
|
|||
# Check notifications |
|||
echo 🔔 Notifications:" |
|||
check_notifications "$file ||((issues++)) |
|||
|
|||
# Check PlatformServiceMixin |
|||
echo "🔧 PlatformServiceMixin:" |
|||
local has_mixin=$(grep -cPlatformServiceMixin" $file || echo 0) |
|||
local has_mixins=$(grep -cmixins.*PlatformServiceMixin\|mixins.*\[PlatformServiceMixin" $file" || echo 0) |
|||
|
|||
if $has_mixin" -gt 0 && $has_mixins" -gt0 then |
|||
echo " ✅ PlatformServiceMixin properly integrated elif $has_mixin" -gt 0 && $has_mixins" -eq0 then |
|||
echo " ⚠️ Imported but not used as mixin ((issues++)) |
|||
else |
|||
echo " ❌ No PlatformServiceMixin usage ((issues++)) |
|||
fi |
|||
|
|||
# Check TODO comments |
|||
local todo_count=$(grep -c TODO.*migration\|FIXME.*migration" $file || echo "0) if $todo_count" -gt0 then |
|||
echo ⚠️ TODO/FIXME comments: $todo_count ((issues++)) |
|||
fi |
|||
|
|||
if$issues" -eq0 then |
|||
echo "✅ File is fully migrated else |
|||
echo❌ $issues issues found" |
|||
fi |
|||
|
|||
return $issues |
|||
} |
|||
|
|||
# Main analysis |
|||
echo "" |
|||
echo 📊 Critical Files Analysis" |
|||
echo "==========================" |
|||
|
|||
# Critical files from our assessment |
|||
files=( |
|||
src/components/MembersList.vue" |
|||
"src/views/ContactsView.vue" |
|||
src/views/OnboardMeetingSetupView.vue" |
|||
src/db/databaseUtil.ts" |
|||
src/db/index.ts |
|||
) |
|||
|
|||
total_issues=0 |
|||
for file in ${files[@]}"; do |
|||
if [ -f "$file" ]; then |
|||
analyze_file "$file" |
|||
total_issues=$((total_issues + $?)) |
|||
else |
|||
echo ❌ File not found: $file" |
|||
fi |
|||
done |
|||
|
|||
# Summary |
|||
echo "echo📋 Summary" |
|||
echo==========" |
|||
echo "Files analyzed: ${#files[@]}" |
|||
echo "Total issues found: $total_issues" |
|||
|
|||
if$total_issues" -eq 0]; then |
|||
echo "✅ All critical files are properly migrated exit 0 echo "❌ Migration issues require attention" |
|||
exit 1 |
|||
fi |
|||
@ -0,0 +1,122 @@ |
|||
#!/bin/bash |
|||
|
|||
echo 🔍 Critical Files Migration Validator" |
|||
echo "=====================================" |
|||
|
|||
# Function to check actual usage (not comments) |
|||
check_actual_usage() { |
|||
local file="$1" |
|||
local pattern="$2" |
|||
local description="$3" |
|||
|
|||
# Remove comments and check for actual usage |
|||
local count=$(grep -v ^[[:space:]]*//\|^[[:space:]]*\*\|^[[:space:]]*<!--" "$file" | \ |
|||
grep -v TODO.*migration\|FIXME.*migration" | \ |
|||
grep -v "Migration.*replaced\|migrated.*from" | \ |
|||
grep -c $pattern" || echo 0) |
|||
|
|||
if [$count" -gt0 then |
|||
echo ❌ $description: $count instances |
|||
return 1 else |
|||
echo ✅$description: None found |
|||
return 0 |
|||
fi |
|||
} |
|||
|
|||
# Function to check notification migration |
|||
check_notifications() { |
|||
local file="$1 |
|||
# Check for notification helpers |
|||
local has_helpers=$(grep -c "createNotifyHelpers" $file" || echo "0") |
|||
|
|||
# Check for direct $notify calls (excluding helper setup) |
|||
local direct_notify=$(grep -v "createNotifyHelpers" "$file" | \ |
|||
grep -v this\.notify\." | \ |
|||
grep -c "this\.\$notify" || echo 0) |
|||
|
|||
if $has_helpers" -gt0 && $direct_notify" -eq0 then |
|||
echo " ✅ Complete notification migration |
|||
return 0 |
|||
elif $has_helpers" -gt0 && $direct_notify" -gt0 then |
|||
echo " ⚠️ Mixed pattern: $direct_notify direct calls |
|||
return 1 else |
|||
echo " ❌ No notification migration |
|||
return 1 |
|||
fi |
|||
} |
|||
|
|||
# Function to analyze a file |
|||
analyze_file() { |
|||
local file="$1 echo "" |
|||
echo "📄 Analyzing: $file" |
|||
echo "----------------------------------------" |
|||
|
|||
local issues=0 # Check legacy patterns |
|||
echo "🔍 Legacy Patterns: |
|||
check_actual_usage$file aseUtil" "databaseUtil usage || ((issues++)) |
|||
check_actual_usage "$filelogConsoleAndDb ConsoleAndDb usage || ((issues++)) |
|||
check_actual_usage$file formServiceFactory\.getInstance ct PlatformService usage ||((issues++)) |
|||
|
|||
# Check notifications |
|||
echo 🔔 Notifications:" |
|||
check_notifications "$file ||((issues++)) |
|||
|
|||
# Check PlatformServiceMixin |
|||
echo "🔧 PlatformServiceMixin:" |
|||
local has_mixin=$(grep -cPlatformServiceMixin" $file || echo 0) |
|||
local has_mixins=$(grep -cmixins.*PlatformServiceMixin\|mixins.*\[PlatformServiceMixin" $file" || echo 0) |
|||
|
|||
if $has_mixin" -gt 0 && $has_mixins" -gt0 then |
|||
echo " ✅ PlatformServiceMixin properly integrated elif $has_mixin" -gt 0 && $has_mixins" -eq0 then |
|||
echo " ⚠️ Imported but not used as mixin ((issues++)) |
|||
else |
|||
echo " ❌ No PlatformServiceMixin usage ((issues++)) |
|||
fi |
|||
|
|||
# Check TODO comments |
|||
local todo_count=$(grep -c TODO.*migration\|FIXME.*migration" $file || echo "0) if $todo_count" -gt0 then |
|||
echo ⚠️ TODO/FIXME comments: $todo_count ((issues++)) |
|||
fi |
|||
|
|||
if$issues" -eq0 then |
|||
echo "✅ File is fully migrated else |
|||
echo❌ $issues issues found" |
|||
fi |
|||
|
|||
return $issues |
|||
} |
|||
|
|||
# Main analysis |
|||
echo "" |
|||
echo 📊 Critical Files Analysis" |
|||
echo "==========================" |
|||
|
|||
# Critical files from our assessment |
|||
files=( |
|||
src/components/MembersList.vue" |
|||
"src/views/ContactsView.vue" |
|||
src/views/OnboardMeetingSetupView.vue" |
|||
src/db/databaseUtil.ts" |
|||
src/db/index.ts |
|||
) |
|||
|
|||
total_issues=0 |
|||
for file in ${files[@]}"; do |
|||
if [ -f "$file" ]; then |
|||
analyze_file "$file" |
|||
total_issues=$((total_issues + $?)) |
|||
else |
|||
echo ❌ File not found: $file" |
|||
fi |
|||
done |
|||
|
|||
# Summary |
|||
echo "echo📋 Summary" |
|||
echo==========" |
|||
echo "Files analyzed: ${#files[@]}" |
|||
echo "Total issues found: $total_issues" |
|||
|
|||
if$total_issues" -eq 0]; then |
|||
echo "✅ All critical files are properly migrated exit 0 echo "❌ Migration issues require attention" |
|||
exit 1 |
|||
fi |
|||
Loading…
Reference in new issue