From 55ed93e91ab94d51d6e2940d869184a4fedb9516 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Matthew Raymer Date: Tue, 8 Jul 2025 08:22:55 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] Add mandatory Pre-Migration Feature Audit to Enhanced Triple Migration Pattern - Create systematic audit template with line-by-line feature documentation - Update migration checklist with mandatory audit as Step 0 - Complete example audit for GiftedPrompts.vue (15-20 min, Simple complexity) - Ensure no functionality is lost during migrations - Provide verification checklist for post-migration testing --- .../COMPLETE_MIGRATION_CHECKLIST.md | 43 ++-- .../PRE_MIGRATION_AUDIT_TEMPLATE.md | 159 ++++++++++++ .../GIFTEDPROMPTS_PRE_MIGRATION_AUDIT.md | 243 ++++++++++++++++++ 3 files changed, 428 insertions(+), 17 deletions(-) create mode 100644 docs/migration-templates/PRE_MIGRATION_AUDIT_TEMPLATE.md create mode 100644 docs/migration-testing/GIFTEDPROMPTS_PRE_MIGRATION_AUDIT.md diff --git a/docs/migration-templates/COMPLETE_MIGRATION_CHECKLIST.md b/docs/migration-templates/COMPLETE_MIGRATION_CHECKLIST.md index ef1cd5de..620eb666 100644 --- a/docs/migration-templates/COMPLETE_MIGRATION_CHECKLIST.md +++ b/docs/migration-templates/COMPLETE_MIGRATION_CHECKLIST.md @@ -84,12 +84,20 @@ git commit -m "[user-approved-message]" ## Pre-Migration Assessment -### [ ] 0. Start Time Tracking +### [ ] 0. Pre-Migration Feature Audit +- [ ] **MANDATORY**: Create detailed feature audit using `docs/migration-templates/PRE_MIGRATION_AUDIT_TEMPLATE.md` +- [ ] Document all database operations with line numbers +- [ ] Document all notification patterns with line numbers +- [ ] Document all template complexity patterns with line numbers +- [ ] Create verification checklist for post-migration testing +- [ ] Assess migration complexity and time requirements + +### [ ] 1. Start Time Tracking - [ ] **MANDATORY**: Run `./scripts/time-migration.sh [ComponentName.vue] start` - [ ] Record start time in terminal output - [ ] Keep terminal open for entire migration process -### [ ] 1. Component Complexity Assessment +### [ ] 2. Component Complexity Assessment - [ ] **Simple** (15-20 min): Dialog components, minimal DB operations, few notifications - [ ] **Medium** (30-45 min): Standard views, moderate DB usage, multiple notifications - [ ] **Complex** (45-60 min): Large views, extensive DB operations, many notifications @@ -100,7 +108,7 @@ git commit -m "[user-approved-message]" - [ ] Use time log to track project progress - [ ] Use historical time durations to improve estimates -### [ ] 2. Identify Legacy Patterns +### [ ] 3. Identify Legacy Patterns - [ ] Count `databaseUtil` imports and calls - [ ] Count raw SQL queries (`SELECT`, `INSERT`, `UPDATE`, `DELETE`) - [ ] Count `$notify()` calls @@ -108,32 +116,32 @@ git commit -m "[user-approved-message]" - [ ] Identify template complexity patterns (repeated expressions, long class strings) - [ ] Document total issues found -### [ ] 3. Verify PlatformServiceMixin Setup +### [ ] 4. Verify PlatformServiceMixin Setup - [ ] Component already imports `PlatformServiceMixin` - [ ] Component already has `mixins: [PlatformServiceMixin]` - [ ] If missing, add mixin first ## Phase 1: Database Migration -### [ ] 4. Replace Database Utility Calls +### [ ] 5. Replace Database Utility Calls - [ ] Remove `import * as databaseUtil from "../db/databaseUtil"` - [ ] Replace `databaseUtil.retrieveSettingsForActiveAccount()` → `this.$accountSettings()` - [ ] Replace `databaseUtil.mapQueryResultToValues()` → `this.$mapQueryResultToValues()` - [ ] Replace other `databaseUtil.*` calls with mixin equivalents -### [ ] 5. Replace Logging Calls +### [ ] 6. Replace Logging Calls - [ ] Remove `import { logConsoleAndDb } from "../db/index"` - [ ] Replace `logConsoleAndDb()` → `this.$logAndConsole()` ## Phase 2: SQL Abstraction Migration -### [ ] 6. Replace Raw Contact Operations +### [ ] 7. Replace Raw Contact Operations - [ ] `SELECT * FROM contacts WHERE did = ?` → `this.$getContact(did)` - [ ] `DELETE FROM contacts WHERE did = ?` → `this.$deleteContact(did)` - [ ] `UPDATE contacts SET x = ? WHERE did = ?` → `this.$updateContact(did, changes)` - [ ] `INSERT INTO contacts` → `this.$insertContact(contact)` -### [ ] 7. Replace Other Raw SQL +### [ ] 8. Replace Other Raw SQL - [ ] `SELECT * FROM settings` → `this.$accountSettings()` - [ ] `UPDATE settings` → `this.$saveSettings(changes)` - [ ] Generic queries → appropriate service methods @@ -141,14 +149,14 @@ git commit -m "[user-approved-message]" ## Phase 2.5: Contact Method Standardization -### [ ] 8. Standardize Contact Fetching Methods +### [ ] 9. Standardize Contact Fetching Methods - [ ] **CRITICAL**: Replace `this.$getAllContacts()` → `this.$contacts()` - [ ] **REASON**: Eliminate inconsistent contact fetching patterns - [ ] **BENEFIT**: All components use same contact data source - [ ] **VALIDATION**: Search for `$getAllContacts` and replace with `$contacts` - [ ] **CONSISTENCY**: All contact operations use unified approach -### [ ] 9. Verify Contact Method Consistency +### [ ] 10. Verify Contact Method Consistency - [ ] **NO** `$getAllContacts()` calls remain in component - [ ] **ALL** contact fetching uses `$contacts()` method - [ ] **CONSISTENT** contact data across component lifecycle @@ -156,18 +164,18 @@ git commit -m "[user-approved-message]" ## Phase 3: Notification Migration -### [ ] 10. Add Notification Infrastructure +### [ ] 11. Add Notification Infrastructure - [ ] Add import: `import { createNotifyHelpers, TIMEOUTS } from "@/utils/notify"` - [ ] Add property: `notify!: ReturnType;` - [ ] Add initialization: `created() { this.notify = createNotifyHelpers(this.$notify); }` -### [ ] 11. Add Notification Constants to Central File +### [ ] 12. Add Notification Constants to Central File - [ ] **CRITICAL**: Add constants to `src/constants/notifications.ts` (NOT local constants) - [ ] Use naming pattern: `NOTIFY_[COMPONENT]_[ACTION]` (e.g., `NOTIFY_OFFER_SETTINGS_ERROR`) - [ ] Import constants: `import { NOTIFY_X, NOTIFY_Y } from "@/constants/notifications"` - [ ] **NO LOCAL CONSTANTS**: All notification text must be centralized -### [ ] 12. Replace Notification Calls +### [ ] 13. Replace Notification Calls - [ ] **Warning**: `this.$notify({type: "warning"})` → `this.notify.warning(CONSTANT.message, TIMEOUTS.LONG)` - [ ] **Error**: `this.$notify({type: "danger"})` → `this.notify.error(CONSTANT.message, TIMEOUTS.LONG)` - [ ] **Success**: `this.$notify({type: "success"})` → `this.notify.success(CONSTANT.message, TIMEOUTS.STANDARD)` @@ -175,7 +183,7 @@ git commit -m "[user-approved-message]" - [ ] **Confirm**: `this.$notify({type: "confirm"})` → `this.notify.confirm(message, onYes)` - [ ] **Standard patterns**: Use `this.notify.confirmationSubmitted()`, `this.notify.sent()`, etc. -### [ ] 13. Constants vs Literal Strings +### [ ] 14. Constants vs Literal Strings - [ ] **Use constants** for static, reusable messages - [ ] **Use literal strings** for dynamic messages with variables - [ ] **Extract literals from complex modals** - Even raw `$notify` calls should use constants for text @@ -183,19 +191,19 @@ git commit -m "[user-approved-message]" ## Phase 4: Template Streamlining -### [ ] 14. Identify Template Complexity Patterns +### [ ] 15. Identify Template Complexity Patterns - [ ] **Repeated CSS Classes**: Long Tailwind strings used multiple times - [ ] **Complex Configuration Objects**: Multi-line objects in template - [ ] **Repeated Function Calls**: Same logic executed multiple times - [ ] **Complex Conditional Logic**: Nested ternary or complex boolean expressions -### [ ] 15. Extract to Computed Properties +### [ ] 16. Extract to Computed Properties - [ ] **CSS Class Groups**: Extract repeated styling to computed properties - [ ] **Configuration Objects**: Move router configs, form configs to computed - [ ] **Conditional Logic**: Extract complex `v-if` conditions to computed properties - [ ] **Dynamic Values**: Convert repeated calculations to cached computed properties -### [ ] 16. Document Computed Properties +### [ ] 17. Document Computed Properties - [ ] **JSDoc Comments**: Add comprehensive comments for all computed properties - [ ] **Purpose Documentation**: Explain what template complexity each property solves - [ ] **Organized Sections**: Group related computed properties with section headers @@ -249,6 +257,7 @@ git commit -m "[user-approved-message]" - [ ] **MANDATORY**: Run `./scripts/time-migration.sh [ComponentName.vue] end` - [ ] Record total duration from terminal output - [ ] Note any blockers or issues that impacted timing +- [ ] **MANDATORY**: Verify all features from pre-migration audit are working ### [ ] 24. Commit with Time Data - [ ] **MANDATORY**: Include time data in commit message diff --git a/docs/migration-templates/PRE_MIGRATION_AUDIT_TEMPLATE.md b/docs/migration-templates/PRE_MIGRATION_AUDIT_TEMPLATE.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..4146126b --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/migration-templates/PRE_MIGRATION_AUDIT_TEMPLATE.md @@ -0,0 +1,159 @@ +# Pre-Migration Feature Audit Template + +## Overview +This template provides a systematic approach to audit all features in a component before migration to ensure no functionality is lost and provide a verification checklist. + +## Component Information +- **Component Name**: [ComponentName.vue] +- **Location**: [src/path/to/Component.vue] +- **Total Lines**: [XXX lines] +- **Audit Date**: [YYYY-MM-DD] +- **Auditor**: Matthew Raymer + +## 📊 Migration Scope Analysis + +### Database Operations Audit +- [ ] **Total Database Operations**: [X operations] +- [ ] **Legacy databaseUtil imports**: [X imports] +- [ ] **PlatformServiceFactory calls**: [X calls] +- [ ] **Raw SQL queries**: [X queries] + +### Notification Operations Audit +- [ ] **Total Notification Calls**: [X calls] +- [ ] **Direct $notify calls**: [X calls] +- [ ] **Legacy notification patterns**: [X patterns] + +### Template Complexity Audit +- [ ] **Complex template expressions**: [X expressions] +- [ ] **Repeated CSS classes**: [X repetitions] +- [ ] **Configuration objects**: [X objects] + +## 🔍 Feature-by-Feature Audit + +### 1. Database Features + +#### Feature: [Feature Name] +- **Location**: Lines [XXX-XXX] +- **Type**: [SELECT/INSERT/UPDATE/DELETE/COUNT/etc.] +- **Current Implementation**: + ```typescript + // Current code snippet + ``` +- **Migration Target**: `this.$methodName()` +- **Verification**: [ ] Functionality preserved after migration + +#### Feature: [Feature Name] +- **Location**: Lines [XXX-XXX] +- **Type**: [Type] +- **Current Implementation**: + ```typescript + // Current code snippet + ``` +- **Migration Target**: `this.$methodName()` +- **Verification**: [ ] Functionality preserved after migration + +### 2. Notification Features + +#### Feature: [Feature Name] +- **Location**: Lines [XXX-XXX] +- **Type**: [success/error/warning/info/toast/confirm] +- **Current Implementation**: + ```typescript + // Current code snippet + ``` +- **Migration Target**: `this.notify.methodName()` +- **Verification**: [ ] Functionality preserved after migration + +### 3. Template Features + +#### Feature: [Feature Name] +- **Location**: Lines [XXX-XXX] +- **Type**: [computed/method/expression/class] +- **Current Implementation**: + ```vue + + ``` +- **Migration Target**: Extract to computed property/method +- **Verification**: [ ] Functionality preserved after migration + +## 🎯 Migration Checklist Totals + +### Database Migration Requirements +- [ ] **Replace databaseUtil imports**: [X imports] → PlatformServiceMixin +- [ ] **Replace PlatformServiceFactory calls**: [X calls] → mixin methods +- [ ] **Replace raw SQL queries**: [X queries] → service methods +- [ ] **Update error handling**: [X patterns] → mixin error handling + +### Notification Migration Requirements +- [ ] **Add notification helpers**: Import createNotifyHelpers +- [ ] **Replace direct $notify calls**: [X calls] → helper methods +- [ ] **Add notification constants**: [X constants] → src/constants/notifications.ts +- [ ] **Update notification patterns**: [X patterns] → standardized helpers + +### Template Streamlining Requirements +- [ ] **Extract repeated classes**: [X repetitions] → computed properties +- [ ] **Extract complex expressions**: [X expressions] → computed properties +- [ ] **Extract configuration objects**: [X objects] → computed properties +- [ ] **Simplify template logic**: [X patterns] → methods/computed + +## 📋 Post-Migration Verification Checklist + +### ✅ Database Functionality Verification +- [ ] All database operations work correctly +- [ ] Error handling functions properly +- [ ] Performance is maintained or improved +- [ ] Data integrity is preserved + +### ✅ Notification Functionality Verification +- [ ] All notification types display correctly +- [ ] Notification timing works as expected +- [ ] User feedback is appropriate +- [ ] Error notifications are informative + +### ✅ Template Functionality Verification +- [ ] All UI elements render correctly +- [ ] Interactive elements function properly +- [ ] Responsive design is maintained +- [ ] Accessibility is preserved + +### ✅ Integration Verification +- [ ] Component integrates properly with parent components +- [ ] Router navigation works correctly +- [ ] Props and events function as expected +- [ ] Cross-platform compatibility maintained + +## 🚀 Migration Readiness Assessment + +### Pre-Migration Requirements +- [ ] **Feature audit completed**: All features documented with line numbers +- [ ] **Migration targets identified**: Each feature has clear migration path +- [ ] **Test scenarios planned**: Verification steps documented +- [ ] **Backup created**: Original component backed up + +### Complexity Assessment +- [ ] **Simple** (15-20 min): Few database operations, minimal notifications +- [ ] **Medium** (30-45 min): Multiple database operations, several notifications +- [ ] **Complex** (45-60 min): Extensive database usage, many notifications, complex templates + +### Dependencies Assessment +- [ ] **No blocking dependencies**: Component can be migrated independently +- [ ] **Parent dependencies identified**: Known impacts on parent components +- [ ] **Child dependencies identified**: Known impacts on child components + +## 📝 Notes and Special Considerations + +### Special Migration Considerations +[Document any unusual patterns, complex logic, or special requirements] + +### Risk Assessment +[Document any potential risks or challenges for this migration] + +### Testing Strategy +[Document specific testing approach for this component] + +--- + +**Template Version**: 1.0 +**Created**: 2025-01-08 +**Author**: Matthew Raymer +**Status**: Ready for use \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/migration-testing/GIFTEDPROMPTS_PRE_MIGRATION_AUDIT.md b/docs/migration-testing/GIFTEDPROMPTS_PRE_MIGRATION_AUDIT.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..f6bdfc45 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/migration-testing/GIFTEDPROMPTS_PRE_MIGRATION_AUDIT.md @@ -0,0 +1,243 @@ +# Pre-Migration Feature Audit - GiftedPrompts.vue + +## Component Information +- **Component Name**: GiftedPrompts.vue +- **Location**: `src/components/GiftedPrompts.vue` +- **Total Lines**: 277 lines +- **Audit Date**: 2025-01-08 +- **Auditor**: Matthew Raymer + +## 📊 Migration Scope Analysis + +### Database Operations Audit +- [x] **Total Database Operations**: 3 operations +- [x] **Legacy databaseUtil imports**: 1 import +- [x] **PlatformServiceFactory calls**: 2 calls +- [x] **Raw SQL queries**: 2 queries + +### Notification Operations Audit +- [x] **Total Notification Calls**: 0 calls +- [x] **Direct $notify calls**: 0 calls +- [x] **Legacy notification patterns**: 0 patterns + +### Template Complexity Audit +- [x] **Complex template expressions**: 2 expressions +- [x] **Repeated CSS classes**: 3 repetitions +- [x] **Configuration objects**: 1 object + +## 🔍 Feature-by-Feature Audit + +### 1. Database Features + +#### Feature: Contact Count Query +- **Location**: Lines 126-133 +- **Type**: COUNT query +- **Current Implementation**: + ```typescript + const platformService = PlatformServiceFactory.getInstance(); + const result = await platformService.dbQuery( + "SELECT COUNT(*) FROM contacts", + ); + if (result) { + this.numContacts = result.values[0][0] as number; + } + ``` +- **Migration Target**: `this.$one()` or `this.$contacts().length` +- **Verification**: [ ] Functionality preserved after migration + +#### Feature: Random Contact Selection +- **Location**: Lines 220-230 +- **Type**: SELECT with LIMIT and OFFSET +- **Current Implementation**: + ```typescript + const platformService = PlatformServiceFactory.getInstance(); + const result = await platformService.dbQuery( + "SELECT * FROM contacts LIMIT 1 OFFSET ?", + [someContactDbIndex], + ); + if (result) { + const mappedContacts = databaseUtil.mapQueryResultToValues(result); + this.currentContact = mappedContacts[0] as unknown as Contact; + } + ``` +- **Migration Target**: `this.$contacts()` with array indexing +- **Verification**: [ ] Functionality preserved after migration + +#### Feature: Database Result Mapping +- **Location**: Lines 227-228 +- **Type**: Result mapping utility +- **Current Implementation**: + ```typescript + const mappedContacts = databaseUtil.mapQueryResultToValues(result); + this.currentContact = mappedContacts[0] as unknown as Contact; + ``` +- **Migration Target**: Use `this.$contacts()` directly (no mapping needed) +- **Verification**: [ ] Functionality preserved after migration + +### 2. Notification Features + +No notification features found in this component. + +### 3. Template Features + +#### Feature: Dynamic Category Icons +- **Location**: Lines 23-24, 60-61 +- **Type**: Conditional icons +- **Current Implementation**: + ```vue + + + ``` +- **Migration Target**: No changes needed (already simple) +- **Verification**: [ ] Functionality preserved after migration + +#### Feature: Repeated Button Styling +- **Location**: Lines 35-40, 64-67 +- **Type**: Repeated CSS classes +- **Current Implementation**: + ```vue + class="text-center bg-gradient-to-b from-slate-400 to-slate-700 shadow-[inset_0_-1px_0_0_rgba(0,0,0,0.5)] text-white px-1.5 py-2 rounded-md mt-4" + ``` +- **Migration Target**: Extract to computed property `buttonClasses` +- **Verification**: [ ] Functionality preserved after migration + +#### Feature: Dynamic Contact Name Display +- **Location**: Lines 31-32 +- **Type**: Complex expression +- **Current Implementation**: + ```vue + {{ currentContact.name || AppString.NO_CONTACT_NAME }} + ``` +- **Migration Target**: Extract to computed property `displayContactName` +- **Verification**: [ ] Functionality preserved after migration + +#### Feature: Router Query Configuration +- **Location**: Lines 156-160 +- **Type**: Configuration object +- **Current Implementation**: + ```typescript + this.$router.push({ + name: "contact-gift", + query: { + prompt: this.IDEAS[this.currentIdeaIndex], + }, + }); + ``` +- **Migration Target**: Extract to computed property `routerConfig` +- **Verification**: [ ] Functionality preserved after migration + +## 🎯 Migration Checklist Totals + +### Database Migration Requirements +- [x] **Replace databaseUtil imports**: 1 import → PlatformServiceMixin +- [x] **Replace PlatformServiceFactory calls**: 2 calls → mixin methods +- [x] **Replace raw SQL queries**: 2 queries → service methods +- [x] **Update error handling**: 0 patterns → mixin error handling + +### Notification Migration Requirements +- [x] **Add notification helpers**: No notification usage found +- [x] **Replace direct $notify calls**: 0 calls → Not needed +- [x] **Add notification constants**: 0 constants → Not needed +- [x] **Update notification patterns**: 0 patterns → Not needed + +### Template Streamlining Requirements +- [x] **Extract repeated classes**: 1 repetition → computed properties +- [x] **Extract complex expressions**: 2 expressions → computed properties +- [x] **Extract configuration objects**: 1 object → computed properties +- [x] **Simplify template logic**: 3 patterns → methods/computed + +## 📋 Post-Migration Verification Checklist + +### ✅ Database Functionality Verification +- [ ] Contact count query returns correct number +- [ ] Random contact selection works properly +- [ ] Contact data is properly typed and accessible +- [ ] Error handling works for database failures + +### ✅ Notification Functionality Verification +- [ ] No notifications to verify (component doesn't use notifications) + +### ✅ Template Functionality Verification +- [ ] Ideas carousel navigation works correctly +- [ ] Contact carousel navigation works correctly +- [ ] Button styling renders consistently +- [ ] Contact name displays correctly (including fallback) +- [ ] Router navigation works with extracted configuration +- [ ] Dialog open/close functionality preserved +- [ ] All interactive elements respond properly + +### ✅ Integration Verification +- [ ] Component opens correctly from parent components +- [ ] Callback functions work properly +- [ ] Router navigation proceeds correctly +- [ ] Contact data integrates properly with other components +- [ ] Dialog overlay and positioning work correctly + +## 🚀 Migration Readiness Assessment + +### Pre-Migration Requirements +- [x] **Feature audit completed**: All features documented with line numbers +- [x] **Migration targets identified**: Each feature has clear migration path +- [x] **Test scenarios planned**: Verification steps documented +- [ ] **Backup created**: Original component backed up + +### Complexity Assessment +- [x] **Simple** (15-20 min): Few database operations, minimal notifications +- [ ] **Medium** (30-45 min): Multiple database operations, several notifications +- [ ] **Complex** (45-60 min): Extensive database usage, many notifications, complex templates + +### Dependencies Assessment +- [x] **No blocking dependencies**: Component can be migrated independently +- [x] **Parent dependencies identified**: Called from various gift recording flows +- [x] **Child dependencies identified**: Navigates to contact-gift route + +## 📝 Notes and Special Considerations + +### Special Migration Considerations +1. **Contact Selection Algorithm**: The random contact selection logic using offset needs careful preservation +2. **Array Indexing**: The `shownContactDbIndices` array logic must be maintained +3. **Router Integration**: The router push with query parameters must work correctly +4. **Callback Pattern**: The `callbackOnFullGiftInfo` callback must be preserved + +### Risk Assessment +- **Low Risk**: Simple database operations, no notifications, minimal template complexity +- **Main Risk**: Ensuring random contact selection algorithm works correctly after migration +- **Mitigation**: Thoroughly test contact carousel functionality + +### Testing Strategy +1. **Manual Testing**: Open dialog, cycle through ideas, test contact carousel +2. **Router Testing**: Verify navigation to contact-gift route with prompts +3. **Database Testing**: Verify contact count and random selection work +4. **Edge Cases**: Test with zero contacts, single contact, many contacts + +## 🔧 Specific Migration Steps + +### Database Migration Steps +1. Add PlatformServiceMixin to component +2. Replace `PlatformServiceFactory.getInstance()` with `this.$contacts()` +3. Replace contact count query with `this.$contacts().length` +4. Replace random selection with array indexing on `this.$contacts()` +5. Remove `databaseUtil.mapQueryResultToValues()` (not needed) + +### Template Streamlining Steps +1. Extract repeated button classes to computed property +2. Extract contact name display logic to computed property +3. Extract router configuration to computed property +4. Add JSDoc comments for all computed properties + +### Verification Steps +1. Test idea carousel navigation (prev/next buttons) +2. Test contact carousel navigation and skip functionality +3. Test "That's it!" button with both ideas and contacts +4. Test dialog cancel functionality +5. Test router navigation with prompt query parameter + +--- + +**Estimated Migration Time**: 15-20 minutes +**Complexity Level**: Simple +**Ready for Migration**: ✅ Yes +**Template Version**: 1.0 +**Created**: 2025-01-08 +**Author**: Matthew Raymer +**Status**: Ready for migration \ No newline at end of file