848 B
848 B
Evidence Packet
Claims used
- ENOCH-REL-001
- ENOCH-REL-002
- ENOCH-NT-001
Primary evidence
- Jude 14–15 quoting Enoch
- Acts 17:28 Greek poet citation
- DSS preservation of Enoch
Comparative evidence
- Baal Cycle as ANE background
- Greek poets as rhetorical sources
Key distinctions
- rhetorical vs framework-bearing
- external vs internal textual world
- explicit attribution vs inferred comparison
Vulnerabilities
Objection
Quotation does not imply authority
Response
- function and context matter
- Jude uses Enoch in judicial argument
Objection
All parallels are just shared culture
Response
- proximity and preservation differ
- explicit attribution changes category
Objection
This inflates Enoch’s importance
Response
- argument is category distinction, not canon expansion